Why Is AARP Final Expense Insurance For Seniors So Much More Expensive?

AARP Final Expense Insurance For Seniors Burial Insurance for Funerals
Kim Wilhelm CEO of Final Expense Direct Life Insurance
Kim Wilhelm on Facebook
Kim Wilhelm on LinkedIn
Kim Wilhelm on Twitter

Written by Kim Wilhelm

Verified!  See guidelines

Verified!  See our editorial guidelines

Last Updated 26 Mar 2023

New York Life has partnered with another very familiar name seniors are well aware of: AARP.

The AARP Final Expense Life Insurance Program from New York Life was created specifically for AARP members.

New York Life is one of the most recognized names in the life insurance industry.

It’s been around for 175 years, offering fully underwritten life insurance through its registered agents, like AARP Life Insurance.

Now, you can get life insurance by New York Life endorsed by AARP at group rates. The AARP Life Insurance Program offers two permanent life insurance options for seniors with the most popular being mailed to you called AARP Level Benefit Term Life. 

Sounds great, right? Unfortunately, many are finding out the hard way it’s not all it’s cracked up to be with AARP charging you way more than their competitors... 

Let’s take a deeper look at what the AARP burial insurance plan offers to seniors and if it’s the right choice for you.

AARP New York Senior Life Insurance Plans

AARP offers several senior life insurance plan options through New York Life. Your age and health status determine what plans you’re eligible for and how much coverage you can get.

AARP New York Life Level Benefit Term Life Insurance

For seniors with temporary coverage needs, AARP offers level benefit term life insurance from New York Life.

Coverage starts at $10,000, with a maximum of $150,000, or $100,000 if you live in Montana or New York. Term life protection lasts until age 80.

However, unlike other companies offering level premiums on term life, AARP New York Life doesn’t. So expect to get low rates initially, then have them increase every five years.

AARP New York Life Permanent Life Insurance

The AARP New York Life permanent life insurance plan is for seniors needing up to $50,000 in lifetime coverage.

The plan offers guaranteed rates that won’t increase and coverage that doesn’t decrease. Although there is no medical exam for approval, you’ll have to answer health questions to qualify.

AARP New York Life Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance

If you’re in poor health and can’t qualify for permanent life insurance, AARP New York Life also has a guaranteed acceptance option.

This product has no medical exam or health questions, and your acceptance is guaranteed. Of course, rates will be higher than for permanent whole life insurance.

And the maximum coverage amount for guaranteed acceptance whole life insurance is $25,000, and it has a 2-year waiting period on the death benefit.

AARP New York Life Rider Benefits

If you buy less than the maximum term life coverage AARP New York Life offers, you can increase to the maximum $150,000 coverage through the AARP Term Rider Protect Plus.

You can also convert up to the maximum coverage from term to whole life if you need permanent coverage. The Guaranteed Exchange Option rates are determined by your current age.

All AARP policies come with an accelerated benefit, which allows you to access some of the death benefit while still alive if you receive a terminal illness diagnosis with less than 24 months to live.

If you’re confined to a nursing home for over 180 consecutive days, the waiver of premium for nursing home stays will kick in. This means premiums are waived until you’re no longer confined or pass away.

Pros and Cons of AARP Final Expense Insurance for Seniors

Buying senior final expense insurance or term insurance from AARP has its pros and cons. Consider these before buying a policy.


  • Term to permanent exchange option
  • Backed by New York Life
  • Online quote and application
  • No medical exam
  • Term and whole life options


  • More expensive than other options
  • Few rider benefits
  • Must be 80 or younger to apply
  • Tough qualifications
  • Must be an AARP member
  • Term rates increase every 5 years

AARP Final Expense Insurance

Most seniors looking for life insurance coverage are looking for it to cover final expenses and burial costs. AARP Final expense life insurance offers lifetime coverage that never decreases and premiums that never increase.

If you die without life insurance, then your loved ones are on the hook for your medical bills and funeral costs, unless you have savings to pay for them. With so many hardworking, God fearing Americans struggling financially, especially seniors, the last thing you probably want to do is make your family or friends pay for your final expenses.

So, maybe you’ve been thinking about buying final expense life insurance for seniors, often called funeral insurance.

AARP Funeral Insurance

The AARP Funeral Life Insurance Program offers funeral life insurance coverage for seniors between the ages of 50 and 80. Your spouse or partner is also eligible for coverage at age 45. If you live in New York, you and your spouse can apply if you are between 50 and 75.

AARP has two options, simplified issue or guaranteed issue. Simplified issue is cheaper and doesn’t require a medical exam, but you have to answer health questions to get approved. If you answer “yes” to any of these questions, you won’t be approved for simplified issue life insurance through AARP:

  • In the last 2 years, have you been diagnosed, treated, or medicated for any immune disorder, heart complications, cancer, lung disease, stroke, AIDS, or kidney disease?
  • In the last 2 years, have you been hospitalized or received skilled nursing care for any illness?
  • In the last 3 months, have been to the doctor, had tests completed, or received treatment for any illness or ailment?

Many people have pre-existing conditions, so that last one is tough for a lot of seniors to answer yes to. If you can’t, then the AARP Funeral Insurance Program has another, more expensive option called AARP Level Benefit Term Life. 

Compare and buy

final expense

Final Expense Life Insurance Quote Online

AARP Burial Insurance Plans

Burial insurance is a guaranteed life insurance policy for seniors. There are no health questions to answer or medical exam to complete. You are guaranteed to be approved, as long as you meet the age requirements. 

If you can qualify for the AARP life insurance simplified issue policy, you can get up to $50,000 in coverage. If not, then the guaranteed issue life insurance policy for seniors is available up to $25,000. It’s not a lot of coverage, but it’s enough to pay for a funeral with viewing and services, or cremation, if you prefer.

AARP Life Insurance For Seniors

When you buy AARP life insurance for seniors, you need to be aware of what isn’t covered. If you die by suicide in the first two years, they won’t pay ANY death benefit to your beneficiary. 

And if you die any other way in the first two years, your beneficiary gets a limited death benefit, which is the amount you paid in premium since you took out the policy, plus 10% interest.

The only way your beneficiary gets the full death benefit in the first two years is if you die by accident.

AARP Senior Life Insurance

When you buy life insurance, you expect the company to pay your death benefit to your beneficiary quickly after you die. Unfortunately for many AARP life insurance policyholders, that doesn’t seem to be the case.

Customers and beneficiaries have submitted AARP life insurance reviews that paint a questionable picture about their senior life insurance products. 

While some only talk about not getting approved or having their down payment mysteriously returned months after not hearing whether they were approved or denied, others talk about being overcharged for payments or their policy canceled without their knowledge.

aarp life insurance review for seniors

Save Money and Headaches By Avoiding AARP Level Benefit Term Life Insurance From New York Life

But it gets worse when a beneficiary files a death benefit claim, especially if the insured died within the first two years.

For many, they turn in all the proper documentation multiple times, only to be told something is missing. New York Life will also do everything they can NOT to approve your claim, even if it’s legitimate. They’ll go back 5 years and look over your medical records with a fine-tooth comb to find any way to contest your payout.

Other life insurance companies have what’s called a contestability period. If you die within the first two years, they can review your application answers and medical history to see if you lied or misrepresented the facts on your life insurance plan application.

Since you get the full death benefit from day 1 with the simplified issue policy, the company will try to avoid paying your beneficiary. 

Why pay all that money to a life insurance company just to have them refuse to pay??? 

AARP Final Expense Insurance For Seniors Burial Insurance for Funerals

We don’t think that’s right, and we’re here to help you. At Final Expense Direct, we only work with the best top rated final expense life insurance companies that won’t hassle your beneficiary at the worst time.

Note:  According to a Penn State University study, 99 percent of all term policies never pay out a claim. Contact us to insure your family receives your life insurance money. 

AARP Life Insurance Costs

So, how much does AARP life insurance plan cost for seniors and grandparents? If you aren’t already an AARP member, you have to become one to even be considered. If you do an automatic renewal with a credit or debit card, it’s $12 a year, or $16 without it. Not too expensive, but still an extra cost if you aren’t already a member.

With AARP, a 50-year-old male would pay $33.18 per month for life insurance. Now, let’s compare that same life insurance policy with Mutual of Omaha. The same man would pay $29.16 a month. 

That $4.02 savings a month doesn’t really sound like much. But, it’s $48.24 over a year, and $482.40 after 10 years. 

Male Rates: Mutual of Omaha vs AARP (NewYorkLife) Compared


Mutual of Omaha


Age 50



Age 55













2022 Sample Quote for life insurance rates for a health standard non-smoking individual. These are examples of rates that may or may not be available to you and you should not rely upon these numbers. Contact Final Expense Direct today to get your personal final expense insurance quote. 1-877-674-0236 Get Your Free Quote Today!

For a senior with a fixed income, those savings can mean a lot. 

Not a great deal.

Mutual of Omaha is just one of the life insurance companies we work with here at Final Expense Direct. We only work with the top final expense life insurance companies offering competitive rates for seniors like you. 

Call us today at Final Expense Direct, where we can get you a better policy with a full death benefit from day 1. Our carriers can also offer more coverage and you can get a better rate than AARP’s “group pricing” — and you still won’t have to take a medical exam!

  • Immediate Approval Over the Phone Today!
  • Speak to a Live Agent 
  • Just a Few Health Questions 

Conclusion - NewYorkLife AARP Insurance

The NewYorkLife AARP Insurance Program offered through New York Life sounds like a great deal. But for seniors looking for a great deal on life insurance policies, it’s anything but. 

AARP life insurance for seniors is expensive, restrictive, and doesn’t offer much coverage. Plus, it seems like a nightmare to get the death benefit paid, especially if you die in the first two years of the policy.

Buyer beware of AARP senior life insurance! If you’re in the market for affordable final expense life insurance, call us at Final Expense Direct — this type of life insurance is all we do! Let us offer you and your family peace of mind, and guaranteed coverage when you need it the most.


  • Get quotes FAST
  • More affordable than you think
  • Compare quotes from top companies
  • Know what you qualify for before you buy!
By pressing "Get Quotes Now" you agree to our privacy policy and consent to have Final Expense Direct contact you by email, phone call, text/SMS message at the phone number & email you provide. You understand that any calls, texts, SMS messages may be made using automated dialing technology. Consent isn’t a condition to purchase our products.